route=hiking relations to discover pre-canned trips (Nov 18, 2026)One thing I want from a hiking app is for it to suggest "pre-canned" trips.
It's not essential. I'm comfortable planning trips on my own from a topographic map. Still, it's nice to get a quick overview of what's available in an area.
So... is that easy? Maybe they already exist in OSM as route=hiking relations?
I did a quick sanity check, using Killarney Provincial Park, as I'm somewhat familiar with it.
It has two very famous hikes, the multi-day La Cloche Silhouette trail and the day-trip to the Crack. The park's website also lists four other hikes along named trails.
The results weren't encouraging:
route=hiking relation.route=hiking relation, but it was wrong -- it only included the first of several ways.I submitted a fix for the Crack, but this suggested that relying on route=hiking would be disappointing.
I spotchecked ~100 other hikes in Canadian parks and the pattern held up: almost all had named trails in OSM, but only ~12% had a relation that followed them.
So maybe you can use the presence of a route=hiking relation to suggest a route, but you can't rely on it.
So... what to do? That's a topic for another time.